Project Engineering – FEED, Detailed Engineering Design & Interface Management
What is Project Engineering?
Project Engineering is the discipline that integrates technical expertise with project management to ensure the successful design, procurement, construction, and commissioning of engineering projects. It bridges the gap between conceptual design and physical implementation, coordinating multidisciplinary teams (process, mechanical, electrical, instrumentation, civil/structural) to deliver solutions that meet technical specifications, safety standards, budget constraints, and schedule requirements.
This page provides a structured breakdown of engineering deliverables across key project phases, with a focus on FEED (Front-End Engineering Design) and Detailed Engineering. The FEED phase establishes the technical foundation, covering process design criteria, preliminary P&IDs, equipment specifications, safety studies (HAZOP/SIL), and cost estimates to ensure project feasibility. The Detailed Engineering phase translates this into execution-ready documents, including final P&IDs, piping isometrics, structural fabrication drawings, electrical schematics, instrumentation loop diagrams, and construction packages. Each discipline (Process, Mechanical, Piping, Electrical, Instrumentation, Civil/Structural) is systematically addressed, highlighting deliverables like hydraulic calculations, material take-offs, control philosophies, and as-built documentation. The content emphasizes compliance with international standards (API, ASME, IEC) while maintaining a practical, bulleted format for clarity and ease of reference in engineering workflows.
Front End Engineering Design (FEED)
Front End Engineering Design (FEED) is the critical first phase in any large-scale oil & gas or industrial engineering project. It involves high-level planning and preliminary design before the actual detailed engineering begins.
Objectives of FEED:
- Define technical requirements and project scope
- Develop preliminary engineering deliverables
- Prepare capital cost estimates
- Identify potential risks and mitigation plans
- Create project schedules and execution strategies
Key FEED Deliverables:
- Process Flow Diagrams (PFDs)
- Piping and Instrumentation Diagrams (P&IDs)
- Equipment lists and process datasheets
- Design philosophies and specifications
- Plot plans and layout drawings
A well-executed FEED phase minimizes scope changes and cost overruns during execution. FEED engineering also forms the technical foundation for bidding and contractor selection.
Detailed Engineering in Oil & Gas Projects
Detailed engineering begins once the FEED phase is complete. It involves the development of final, construction-ready documents and drawings that drive procurement, construction, commissioning, and operation.
Detailed engineering ensures design integrity, constructability, and compliance with technical standards. This phase also supports procurement and vendor management.
Discipline-wise Breakdown:
Given below is discipline wise list of deliverables for each engineering discipline.
| Project Phase | Process Engineering Deliverables |
|---|---|
| Feasibility & Conceptual Design |
• Process Design Basis Memorandum (DBM)
• Block Flow Diagrams (BFDs)
• Preliminary Mass & Energy Balances
• Process Flow Diagrams (PFDs) – Draft
• Equipment List (Preliminary)
• Process Control Philosophy
• HAZID Report
• CAPEX & OPEX Estimates
|
| Basic Engineering (FEED) |
• Final PFDs
• P&IDs – Draft
• Process Datasheets
• Utility Summary Diagrams
• Process Safeguarding Diagrams
• HAZOP Study Report
• SIL Assessment
• EIA Process Inputs
• Process Control Narrative
• Relief Calculations
• Chemical Consumption Estimates
|
| Detailed Engineering |
• Final P&IDs (IFC)
• Piping Material Specs
• Equipment Layout Plans
• Nozzle Orientation Diagrams
• Line List
• Hydraulic Analysis
• Thermodynamic Simulations
• Vent/Drain Sizing
• Control Valve Sizing
• Instrument Datasheets
• Cause & Effect Diagrams
• Alarm Settings
|
| Construction & Commissioning |
• As-Built P&IDs
• Pre-Commissioning Checklists
• Performance Test Protocols
• Troubleshooting Guides
|
| Handover & Closeout |
• Final Engineering Package
• Lessons Learned Report
• Optimization Recommendations
|
Compliant with API, ASME, ISA, and IEC standards
| Project Phase | Mechanical Engineering Deliverables |
|---|---|
| Feasibility & Conceptual Design |
• Equipment List (Preliminary)
• Mechanical Design Basis
• Equipment Layout Concepts
• Material Selection Guidelines
|
| Basic Engineering (FEED) |
• Equipment Datasheets
• Mechanical Calculations
• Piping Load Analysis
• Vendor Drawing Reviews
|
| Detailed Engineering |
• Fabrication Drawings
• Stress Analysis Reports
• Welding Specifications
• Inspection & Test Plans
|
| Construction & Commissioning |
• As-Built Drawings
• Equipment Installation Records
• Mechanical Completion Certificates
|
| Handover & Closeout |
• Final Documentation Package
• Maintenance Manuals
• Spare Parts List
|
Compliant with ASME, API, and ISO standards
| Project Phase | Civil/Structural Engineering Deliverables |
|---|---|
| Feasibility & Conceptual Design |
• Site Selection Report
• Geotechnical Investigation
• Preliminary Foundation Concepts
|
| Basic Engineering (FEED) |
• Structural Calculations
• Foundation Layouts
• Load Analysis
|
| Detailed Engineering |
• Reinforcement Details
• Steel Fabrication Drawings
• Bill of Quantities
|
| Construction & Commissioning |
• Construction Method Statements
• Quality Control Plans
• As-Built Drawings
|
| Handover & Closeout |
• Final Structural Certificates
• Settlement Monitoring Reports
• Handover Documentation
|
Compliant with ACI, AISC, and Eurocode standards
| Project Phase | Piping Deliverables |
|---|---|
| Feasibility & Conceptual Design |
• Piping Material Specifications
• Preliminary Line List
• Piping Layout Concepts
|
| Basic Engineering (FEED) |
• P&IDs
• Pipe Stress Analysis
• Valve Datasheets
• Piping Support Standards
|
| Detailed Engineering |
• Isometric Drawings
• Piping GA Drawings
• Bill of Materials
• Fabrication Details
|
| Construction & Commissioning |
• As-Built P&IDs
• Hydrotest Packages
• Pipe Support Certificates
|
| Handover & Closeout |
• Final Piping Documentation
• Pipe Wall Thickness Reports
• Maintenance Recommendations
|
Compliant with ASME B31.3, API, and ANSI standards
| Project Phase | Deliverables |
|---|---|
| Feasibility & Conceptual Design |
• Load List
• Single Line Diagrams (SLD)
• Preliminary Cable Schedules
|
| Basic Engineering (FEED) |
• Equipment Layouts
• Hazardous Area Classification
• Earthing & Lightning Protection
|
| Detailed Engineering |
• Cable Routing Drawings
• Termination Details
• Motor Control Schematics
|
| Construction & Commissioning |
• Cable Test Reports
• Relay Settings
• Loop Check Reports
|
| Handover & Closeout |
• As-Built Drawings
• Operation & Maintenance Manuals
• Spare Parts List
|
Compliant with IEC, NEC, and IEEE standards
| Project Phase | Instrumentation and Control Deliverables |
|---|---|
| Feasibility & Conceptual Design |
• Instrument List
• Control Philosophy
• Preliminary I/O List
|
| Basic Engineering (FEED) |
• Instrument Datasheets
• Cause & Effect Diagrams
• Junction Box Layouts
|
| Detailed Engineering |
• Loop Diagrams
• Control Panel Drawings
• Cable Schedule
|
| Construction & Commissioning |
• Calibration Reports
• Loop Check Sheets
• Functional Test Procedures
|
| Handover & Closeout |
• As-Built Documentation
• Final Loop Folders
• Maintenance Manuals
|
Compliant with ISA, IEC, and ANSI standards
Engineering Discipline Interface Management
Interface management is critical to the success of multidisciplinary engineering projects. It ensures effective communication, data flow, and coordination between engineering disciplines and stakeholders.
Common Engineering Interfaces:
- Process ↔ Mechanical (e.g., flowrate vs. pump specs)
- Piping ↔ Civil (e.g., pipe rack loads on foundations)
- Instrumentation ↔ Electrical (e.g., instrument power supply routing)
- Mechanical ↔ Structural (e.g., equipment nozzle orientation vs. platform supports)
Best Practices for Interface Management:
- Maintain an up-to-date Interface Register
- Use Interface Control Documents (ICDs)
- Conduct regular interdisciplinary coordination meetings
- Assign clear interface ownership and responsibilities
Effective interface management helps prevent costly rework, delays, and design conflicts during execution.
Project Engineering Tools & Templates
Project engineers use a variety of tools and templates to monitor progress, track documents, and ensure timely communication across teams.
Useful Tools:
- Engineering document trackers (Excel or EDMS-based)
- Interface registers and follow-up logs
- Document transmittal and approval logs
- Material Take-Off (MTO) and BOQ templates
- Technical Bid Evaluation (TBE) templates
- Design review and comment resolution sheets
Document Control and Engineering Workflow
Engineering document control is essential to ensure traceability, consistency, and regulatory compliance throughout the project lifecycle.
Key Concepts:
- RACI Matrix – Defines roles (Responsible, Accountable, Consulted, Informed)
- Engineering Workflow – Initial drafting → IDC → Client review → Final issue
- Engineering Document Management System (EDMS) – Digital platforms that manage revisions, transmittals, approvals, and document status
A structured document control process prevents the use of outdated or incorrect documents during construction or procurement.
Case Studies & Lessons Learned in Project Engineering
Case 1: Vendor Delay Impact on Layouts
Delayed vendor data for a major compressor required last-minute updates to the piping layout. This caused rework, manpower rescheduling, and procurement changes, impacting the overall construction schedule.
Here’s a well-structured table summarizing the **Process Engineering Deliverables for a Greenfield Plant**:
Case 2: Interface Mismanagement in Cable Trenches
Lack of coordination between civil and electrical teams led to misaligned cable trenches. As-built corrections delayed the electrical installation by two weeks.
Lesson: Proactive interface management and vendor engagement are crucial for avoiding project delays.
Related Engineering Resources
Explore related content to deepen your understanding: